UPDATE: Note the WORDPRESS BUG code fix in post #14 you need this fixed and the comment.php in post #8
==================
Update: Grab the comment.zip in post#36 to fix this
==================

There is a bug in the comment code which causes the comment form not to show up after the first comment is made on a 'PAGE' page. To fix this bug do the following

Edit comment.php and find line 79-80 (versions 341/344) which should be

<?php // If comments are open
if ('open' == $post->comment_status) : ?>

and replace them with the following

<?php // If comments are open
if ( ('open' == $post->comment_status) 
OR ( is_page() and ('Yes' == $bfa_ata[comments_on_pages]) and ('open' == $post->comment_status) )) : ?>

save the file to the host and you should be all set.

Hi again Juggledad, thanks for the fix, works perfect... thanks again

works for me too! Thanks!

http://www.betsysbabyservices.com/

I updated the fix so the form won't show when the comments are closed on the page - Thanks to Keikurono for spotting that!

Well I don't know about the original fix. But the updated fix does not work for me. Form is only shown on pages without any posts. On other pages people can use "reply" but the comment form only shows for pages without any comment.

I see I'd better go back to the drawing board and try
1) a page with no comments - comments open
2) a page with no comments - comments closed
3) a page with comments - comments open
4) a page with comments - comments closed

Hi, thanks again for the fix on the comments form but now i want to know if there is any way for hidding the form on some pages where commenting is not allowed (example > http://www.shito-anime.net/?page_id=2324)

even knowing the comments are closed, the form still appears, i want to hide it..

thanks....

Originally Posted by juggledad

==================
Update: Grab the comment.zip in post#8 to fix this
==================

There is a bug in the comment code which causes the comment form not to show up after the first comment is made on a 'PAGE' page. To fix this bug do the following

Edit comment.php and find line 79-80 (versions 341/344) which should be

<?php // If comments are open
if ('open' == $post->comment_status) : ?>

and replace them with the following

<?php // If comments are open
if ( ('open' == $post->comment_status) 
OR ( is_page() and ('Yes' == $bfa_ata[comments_on_pages]) and ('open' == $post->comment_status) )) : ?>

save the file to the host and you should be all set.

Hi,
I'm having the same problem.

I did replace the code in comment.php, but I'm still experiencing the same problem. Only one comment is accepted on pages.

NOTE: There are two parts to fix this problem

1) replace comment.php in the atahualpa folder with the attached file (unzip it first) and
2) fix the WordPress code described in post 14

comments.php.zip

Originally Posted by juggledad

NOTE: There are two parts to fix this problem

1) replace comment.php in the atahualpa folder with the attached file (unzip it first) and
2) fix the WordPress code described in post 14

Attachment 392

Hi Juggledad:

I am trying to fix this bug but having problems.

1. I cannot unzip the file because it says I do not have the program on my computer to open the attached file for comment.php What file can I download to unzip the comment.php file?

2. I am having problems finding the file you mentioned in post 14. Is it the same as the comment.php file or in the FTP files?

1) do a google search for 'unzip programs' and download one for your operating system

2) this is one of WordPress's files

...edit comment-template.php (it's in the wp-includes folder) and find the function...

Hi Juggledad;
Thanks for this bugfix. I managed to get it working yesterday after a bit of fiddling about, and I have now got multiple comments on single pages. That had been annoying me for a while.
However, I am finding that the 'highlight author comments in different colour' option in ATO > 'style and configure COMMENTS' doesn't seem to work on the single pages. I think it's still OK on the multi-post pages, but single-post comment replies all seem to be in the default comment colour, e.g. here.

I'm using WP 2.9.2 and Ata 3.4.6.