I tested two different Atahualpa installs with the newest wordpress and if you turn on comments for PAGES as well it will obviously now show up as long as you have it enabled for that page, but after the 1st person posts, you can no longer post on that page? Has anyone else posted this? I cannot seem to find anyone else having this problem but I did a clean install to replicate the problem and found it out again. Can someone work with me on resolving this problem.

I have the same problem. Comment-form not showing after user posts one comment. WP 2.9.1 and Atahualpa 3.4.5.1, However comment-form shows again when switching to Atahualpa 3.3.3.

so, who can we bring this bug to to report it and resolve this?

Try contacting Flynn, the developer of the theme.

In the meantime, have you tried a comment system like Disqus?

have you looked in the Comments, trackbacks & pings Forum at the sticky 'BUGFIX - 3.4.1/3.4.4 - Comment form will not show up after first comment on a PAGE'?

perfect! SORRY I did note even notice that there was a sub form! My apologizes, I usually look high and low before posting, the zip file you made is perfect, need to make that part of the theme if it is not already, you rock