I have been trying to figure this out on my own with Firebug and the forums and haven't yet found the answer I'm looking for. The words "name," "email" and "website" are set in a font that doesn't match the rest of my site, and I also want them to be in a different color. How can I control that? I'm assuming it needs to be changed with CSS inserts, but I'm pretty new to CSS. My url is http://jillmorrison.net/cuba/colon-cemetery/

Try this in ATO>Add HTML/CSS Inserts>CSS Inserts
#commentform label {
color: #put color code here;
font-family: put font family you want here;
}

Perfect, thanks!