Hi there!
I have the problem this user was experiencing: http://forum.bytesforall.com/showthread.php?t=4440

and yet my problem did not "fix itself." Not yet anyway. I have the same footer for Home Page, Multi Post Pages and Single Posts, and I attached a file to show you what it looks like. Here's my site:

www.otteny.com/blog

So the problem is just like she said, clicking on posts reveals the sharing icons but they won't show up on the homepage.

I'm in Atahualpa 3.5.3

You may have to add some tags to the don't strip these tags box in the excerpts section of the theme options.