With iPhone/iPad, my website links work only ONCE, then loop to 'newest entry'

Hello from an unsavvy user (i have no knowledge of php/html)

Navigation of my website is perfectly fine with PC/Mac desktop/laptops, but when viewed with iPhone/iPad all links only redirect to the proper page when clicked the FIRST time. All subsequent clicked links loop back to the latest post (For instance when clicking "older entries" for the second time, it loops back to home page.)
Details:
* My website is www.misterfreedom.com
* WP 3.4.1 with Atahualpa 3.7.8 (customized by a 3rd party who admits not understanding the problem)
* I have tried with and without iPhone compatibility plug-in (all mobile related plugins are disabled and deleted now.)
* My hosting service (register.com) says I have no record for "m." redirecting in my DNS, but have a catchall in my A record (therefore the redirect to m.misterfreedom.com with iPhone viewing)
* I am not sure when this started happening, nor could i find the same issue documented in this forum.
* Currently installed/activated plugins are: Add Meta Tags/April's Super Function Pack/Column Matic/Contact From7/Custom Meta/Google Analyticator/Google Analytics for WP/InstantUpgrade/NextGEN Gallery/Page Links to/Really Simple CAPTCHA/the Social Links/WP Data backup/WP Facebook like plugin/WP-Highslide/WP MulticolLinks/WP re-CAPTCHA

Any experience with this issue? Thank you so much for your time and thoughts.