I have only a handful of settings which differ from Atahualpa's default options. When I used Reset All options, a significant number of those settings were not reset to defaults:

(This is not a comprehensive list)

Configure SEO
 Noindex date archive pages?
 Noindex category pages?
 Noindex tag pages?
 Nofollow RSS, trackback & admin links?

Style & edit HEADER AREA
 Search box
 Text in header search box
 Horizontal Bar 1: Styling
 Horizontal Bar 2: Styling

Configure EXCERPTS
 Don't strip these tags

Style IMAGES
 Images in Posts

Add HTML/CSS Inserts
 CSS Inserts

There were some options that were reset correctly, like hover tables and show logo next to title.

Sometimes the database needs a bit of cleaning too.

In the ATO --> Import/Export Settings

Scroll down near the bottom and click on the "Delete the bfa_ata4" button and see if that helps.

did you ever have a version prior to 3.4.7 installed? In that case the old settings are still in the database and pressing the reset all or delete bfa4 will rebuild the options from the database.

The reset al should copy in the settings from the 'classic' setting file

Originally Posted by juggledad

did you ever have a version prior to 3.4.7 installed? In that case the old settings are still in the database and pressing the reset all or delete bfa4 will rebuild the options from the database.

The reset al should copy in the settings from the 'classic' setting file

I have Atahualpa installed manually to /wp-content/themes/atahualpa364 so there should not be any stray files from previous versions around. Seems to be strictly database related.

Let me ask the question in a different was

Did you ever use a version of atahualpa earlier than 3.4.7 with this database?

Originally Posted by juggledad

Let me ask the question in a different was

Did you ever use a version of atahualpa earlier than 3.4.7 with this database?

It is likely, but I cannot remember for sure. I know that I had 3.4.9 installed for quite some time, but I'm not positive that I started with it.

Originally Posted by runnerb0y

Sometimes the database needs a bit of cleaning too.

In the ATO --> Import/Export Settings

Scroll down near the bottom and click on the "Delete the bfa_ata4" button and see if that helps.

The effect of "Delete the bfa_ata4" was no different than "Reset ALL theme options". The same set of options which were not reset before are still not reset now.

Thanks for the info. I have passed this along.