I added these lines under CSS Inserts to get the look I wanted on the homepage but when I click on a category or archive it doesn't translate well.

.blog .post-headline h2 {
padding-left:230px;
text-align:left !important;
}
.post img {
float:left;
margin-top:-60px !important;
margin-bottom:20px !important;
}

I am running Atahualpa 3.7.13 and Wordpress 3.8

take a look:
http://www.gillicutti.com/
http://www.gillicutti.com/?cat=1

where did you get the class 'blog' from?

Thanks for pointing that out. I found the line on this forum but it was incorrect. Some searching brought me to this post and it works now.

div.post-headline h2 {
display:block;
margin-left:230px;
}
div.post-bodycopy img.wp-post-image {
float:left;
margin-top: -60px;
}