[SOLVED] Home Page Linking to Random page??

Okay, I'm confused. I was adding subpages into the theme, and when I checked it on the main page, I was unable to get to the home link. Thinking there might have been an issue with the page, I deleted it. However.. my home link still doesn't work- it goes right to the page link.

I am using Atahualpa 3.5.1 and Wordpress 3.0 (set it up on here, did not upgrade).

Home page is: http://www.healthhomehappy.com

When I type that it, or click on the Home Link (which I do have enabled in the ATO --> Page Menu Bar), I get to http://www.healthhomehappy.com/grain-free/macaroons (The page & subpage I deleted).

Can anyone shed some light on this here? I tried putting the permalinks settings back to the default, but that just ticked it off and started returning 404 errors. So I changed them back to custom permalinks.

Any help would be greatly appreciated.