Each page shows "comments are closed" at the bottom. I want all pages to be able to be commented on (for now).

There is one page which someone has somehow managed to leave a comment and that page does not show this message at the bottom. That was several weeks ago and when i had another theme.

I've done the following (it's been that way all along):
1) ATO->Style & configure COMMENTS->Allow comments on "Page" pages, too? must be set to YES
2) dashboard->Pages->Edit->page-you-want->Discussion->Allow Comments - must be checked.

Just now I deactivated all my plugins and no change.

Also, I've spent some time searching the WP.org forums. I've found the issue raised several times but none resolved. Example: http://wordpress.org/support/topic/258518?replies=6.

Atahualpa 3.4.2
WP 2.8.3

Scott

what is your url?

http://scottswebshop.org/wp2/

Just now I published some content on the home page and the comments are opened. On one other page there is content, another none yet. Both still say "Comments closed."

What plugins do you have? I'm woundering where the 'subscribe without commenting' comes from at the bottom of the page if you select the 'Scott’s Web Shop' tag?

I have about a dozen. The ones that seem pertinent are:
Subscribe to comments
Subscribe to comments now
WP Ajax Edit Comments
Contact Form 7

The others:
Akismet
All in One SEO Pack
Bad Behavior
Google XML Sitemaps
Hello Dolly
Search Docs
Sociable
WordPress Database Backup
WordPress Mobile Edition
WP-PageNavi
WP-Print