I had all my menu icons setup the way I wanted them, and then I setup a 'drop down' menu and assigned the menu to the Menu 1 theme. Since I did that I have two menu icons that are just displaying the 'default' star icon. Try as I might I can't change them.

Here is the menu icon coding I'm using:

/* Part 1- for default state: */
#menu1 .page-reviews > a > i { background-position: 0px -336px; }
#menu1 .page-landman-books > a > i { background-position: 0px -2112px; }
#menu1 .page-jobs > a > i { background-position: 0px -1272px; }
#menu1 .page-advertise-with-us > a > i { background-position: 0px -888px; }
#menu1 .page-contact-us > a > i { background-position: 0px -96px; }
/* Part 2 - for hover state: */
#menu1 .page-reviews:hover > a > i, #menu1 .page-reviews.active > a > i { background-position: -24px -336px; }
#menu1 .page-landman-books:hover > a > i, #menu1 .page-landman-books.active > a > i { background-position: -24px -2112px; }
#menu1 .page-jobs:hover > a > i, #menu1 .page-jobs.active > a > i { background-position: -24px -1272px; }
#menu1 .page-advertise-with-us:hover > a > i, #menu1 .page-advertise-with-us.active > a > i { background-position: -24px -888px; }
#menu1 .page-contact-us:hover > a > i, #menu1 .page-contact-us.active > a > i { background-position: -24px -96px; }

The url is www.landmaninsider.com\

Any suggestions on how to make them display the correct icon?

It looks like you have a caching plugin. The first step is to clear the cache to see if that is the issue.

I'm using W3, and I've emptied the W3 cache, and also locally just for safe measure.

The menu icons worked as intended before I setup the drop down menu.

edit: firebug shows that it isn't setting background-position for the menu items?

what is the class you assigned to the job custom menu item?

I haven't assigned any class in the menu settings? (title attribute???) The actual page is just setup to redirect to jobs.landmaninsider.com -- which hasn't thrown problems before.

I did a quick test, and when I set the Menu 1 in theme location to blank then it reverts to the 'normal' menu and the icons work.

When I turn on the Menu 1 in theme location then it doesn't work.

I'm not sure if this can narrow down the issue or not...

OK! Fixed it! Since I was redirecting the page to a subdomain URL, I needed to not call the 'page' and add a custom URL in the Menu setup. That corrected the issue. So apparently it just doesn't play nice with a "Page Links To" plugin I was using before I started using the custom menu setup.