Header and Footer not displaying in site on new server

The original site is:

http://bathshebaspooner.com/

we are moving this to a new server, and have the migrated site at:

http://bathshebaspooner.apps-1and1.com/

Everything seems to have carried over except the header and the footer, which are not displaying. I have checked the header settings, and other details, but am unable to find inconsistencies with the original.

I am not certain this is a theme issue, but I don't know where else to start.

Your thoughts?

Thanks very much.
Gordon Peery