Admin deleted theme options - Need help restoring

An old client is running Atahualpa at compulsivefoodie.com. She updated in the WP admin, and then panicked when the header wasn't there (sigh) and clicked to reset all theme options "because it looked like an undo button."

I've run a site restore through Bluehost and I can't figure out why it isn't restoring the theme options. They checked today to make sure the database was also restored (to a point on 12/4, which should work since she borked the site today.)

Any help is welcome. And yeah, I'll be downloading a backup of her theme options from now on.