when i enable "Enable threaded (nested) comments (1-9) levels deep" in wordpress setting-discussion,
my page comment(i have enabled the page comment in Atahualpa) will display all the comments in last comment page, even i have already enabled "Break comments into pages with 19 comments per page and the page displayed by default"

when i disable "Enable threaded (nested) comments levels deep", the last comment page will display only 19 comments, then go to next comment page

the confusing is if i disabled "Enable threaded (nested) comments levels deep", there's no thread mode in comments


this bug is from 3.4.2 to 3.4.4

does the same problem happen if the '"Break comments into pages with 19 comments' is changed to say '5'?

Originally Posted by juggledad

does the same problem happen if the '"Break comments into pages with 19 comments' is changed to say '5'?

yes, whatever which number i set
the problem is if i enabled both "Enable threaded (nested) comments levels deep" and "Break comments into pages with comments per page and the page displayed by default", the bug reprod
if i only leave "Break comments into pages with comments per page and the page displayed by default" and disabled "Enable threaded (nested) comments levels deep", bug disappeared.

i really need "Enable threaded (nested) comments levels deep" function, and need help here

Are you talking about the comments and replys? i.e. Lets say I have comments breaking at 5 and I have a post with 13 comments and the last three comments have 1 reply each. The first page of comments would show 5 comments, the second would show 5 and the last would show 6 (3 comments and 3 replys) Is this what you are seeing?

can you point to your url so I can see hwat is happening?

Originally Posted by juggledad

Are you talking about the comments and replys? i.e. Lets say I have comments breaking at 5 and I have a post with 13 comments and the last three comments have 1 reply each. The first page of comments would show 5 comments, the second would show 5 and the last would show 6 (3 comments and 3 replys) Is this what you are seeing?

can you point to your url so I can see hwat is happening?

sure, http://ricky119.com/chinesesupport/



here's my current setting in wordpress. the last page shows all the comments not 10
Enable threaded (nested) comments 3 levels deep
Break comments into pages with 10 comments per page and the page displayed by default

Originally Posted by ricky119

sure, http://ricky119.com/chinesesupport/



here's my current setting in wordpress. the last page shows all the comments not 10
Enable threaded (nested) comments 3 levels deep
Break comments into pages with 10 comments per page and the page displayed by default

do we have any solution?