[SOLVED] Multiple excepts/posts on Category Pages

First, thanks for a great theme. I've been setting up my first WP site with your theme and have found it very flexible and easy to use.

I've searched the forum for an answer to my problem and have tried for weeks to figure this out myself, so if I missed a discussion on this somewhere, I apologize. Here's what I'd like to do on my site:

Have only 1 post show on the Multi-Post page since it's what shows up by default on my home(Journal) page and have multiple posts appear on my Category Pages (when people link in to my categories from the widget on the Journal page). But, it appears that by setting the home/Journal page as showing only 1 post, it also only shows 1 post on all other Category pages and I don't see any option in the settings to change how many posts are displayed on the Category page. I'd be happy with just having the Individual posts appearing on the Journal page (instead of the multiple-post option) and then setting up the multi-post pages to show more than 1 post, but I can't figure out how to only show the individual posts on the home/Journal page (and I'm not sure that would be logical either).

If I'm being too vague in my explanation or you need more info, let me know. I'm new to WP and this theme.

I'm using Atahualpa 3.4.6 and my site is 2cycle2gether.com if you want to take a look at how I currently have it set up.

Thanks for any help!