if You will send me a PM with a admin ID/pw I'll take a look, might not be till tomorrow afternoon though

Upgrade your Atahualpa.

I just ran into the same issue - folks were coming to my site, and getting the message "you must be logged in to comment" - even when they were logged in.

I couldn't comment either - and this was working fine before. (the site's been up forever.)

Upgraded ATA - and all is well.

Hope this helps!

Mark

I'm experiencing this same problem.
I have someone using Atahualpa 3.6.7 and Wordpress 3.2.1
Not checked: Users must be registered and logged in to comment
Allow Comments is checked for the page comments are welcomed.
http://www.guthriegroup.com/contact/your-project/
Any ideas?
Thanks!
Cway

I see comments on some of the posts. Where can't people make comments?

what is ato->Style & configure COMMENTS->Allow comments on "Page" pages, too?

That was it.
Thanks!